When Luke Talich had to leave the Notre Dame game against SMU, whatever was wrong with his leg or ankle didn't look good. The veteran safety wasn't in the locker room long; when he returned to the sidelines in a large boot and on crutches, his demeanor didn't suggest he thought the injury was minor. On Sunday morning, reports indicated that it's a worst-case scenario for a player who was having a breakout 2026.
Matt Zenitz reported on Twitter that the Fighting Irish fear that Talich suffered a torn Achilles tendon.
Notre Dame star safety Luke Talich is feared to have suffered a torn Achilles vs. SMU yesterday, sources tell me and @chris_hummer.
— Matt Zenitz (@mzenitz) November 22, 2026
Awaiting the results of further testing but that’s the fear. Has been one of No. 6 Notre Dame’s top players and had been emerging as a first round… pic.twitter.com/XzQBfKidJM
Notre Dame safety Luke Talich feared to have torn Achilles tendon against SMU
Zenitz added that the Irish are awaiting the results of further testing, but an Achilles tear is the fear for now. If that is the case, it's a nightmare for Notre Dame, as it would obviously mean Talich would miss the College Football Playoff. It would be an even bigger nightmare for the player, who was having such a successful season that he'd started to generate buzz as a first-round selection in the 2027 NFL Draft.
If he did tear his Achilles, it's extremely unlikely he'd be able to play much of the 2027 NFL season, and he'd likely miss the entire year. It would also mean that, barring an NFL team wanting to make sure no one else grabbed him, any chance of an early draft pick is gone.
Even if Talich somehow avoids the worst-case scenario of an Achilles tear, even a strain would likely mean he’s out for the rest of the season. That’s especially a gut punch for a player who has already fought back from a broken hand after finally earning a starting job when Brauntae Johnson was injured in Notre Dame’s season opener.
This season, Talich is tied for the team lead in tackles with 47 and leads the team in interceptions with 3. He’s also got 5 pass breakups and 2 forced fumbles.
How a Luke Talich Achilles tear would impact Notre Dame football
From a Notre Dame perspective, the silver lining on this very dark cloud is that Johnson returned to practice this past week and looked ready to play against SMU if his number had been called.
When Talich left the game, he was replaced by true freshman Joey O’Brien, who has served as Talich’s backup for most of the season.
If Talich misses the rest of Notre Dame’s season, the Fighting Irish will likely start O’Brien against Syracuse and slowly work Johnson into the game, hoping to get him up to speed by the start of the College Football Playoff.

