Skip to main content

Winners and losers after Notre Dame football nabs gritty win over SMU Mustangs

The Fighting Irish weren't pretty against SMU, but a few players made sure it didn't matter.
ByOliver Vandervoort
Notre Dame wide receiver Jordan Faison catches a pass in the end zone for a touchdown during the game against Southern Methodist
Notre Dame wide receiver Jordan Faison catches a pass in the end zone for a touchdown during the game against Southern Methodist | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

The Notre Dame football team didn't look perfect on Saturday night. The offense, especially, seemed out of whack for one reason or another. On the other hand, the Fighting Irish defense held an SMU offense that had been explosive for most of the season to just 3 points.

Just how good was the defense in the 24-3 win? The Mustangs managed to get into the red zone three times, but they came up empty each time. It wasn't the prettiest win in the Marcus Freeman era, but the team took care of business on a night when College Football Playoff chaos erupted across the country.

So, who were the winners and the losers in Notre Dame's latest win?

Winners and losers from Notre Dame's win over SMU

Winner - Jordan Faison

On a night when the Notre Dame offense struggled to find a rhythm, Jordan Faison stood up and showed he can be the kind of "go-to" receiver the Fighting Irish need in the College Football Playoff. Faison caught 7 passes for 109 yards and a touchdown. Oh my, what a touchdown catch.

Quarterback CJ Carr's throw was a little off target, but that didn't faze Faison, who reached up with one paw and hauled it down, making sure he got his feet in bounds near the edge of the end zone. The catch was so good that the official CFP social media account was impressed. That catch also made up for the fact that he fumbled for the second time in two games.

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

Loser - Luke Talich

Talich isn't a loser because he had a bad game on the field. He's a loser in this game because he couldn't finish it. It's been a heck of a roller-coaster season for the safety. He entered 2026 as a backup to Brauntae Johnson but showed what he can do when Johnson went down. Unfortunately, Saturday's injury was his second of the season. The way he looked on the sidelines, wearing a big boot and using crutches, made it seem like he'd been told his season was likely over.

Winner - Kendrick Rafael

SMU running back Kendrick Rafael did something against Notre Dame that no other running back has done this season. He also did a couple of things very few players have managed. Rafael helped scare Notre Dame with a 70-yard dash right up the middle. It was not only the longest run any opponent had against the Irish this year, but also more than 30 yards longer than the next-longest.

Rafael finished the night with exactly 100 yards on the ground. He became just the second player to hit the century mark against Chris Ash's unit, and he did it on 12 carries while Navy quarterback Jackson Gutierrez needed 28. That distinction also means Rafael is the only running back to run for 100 yards against the Irish this season.

Loser - Christian Gray

While the Notre Dame defense made the night miserable for SMU quarterback Kevin Jennings, one defensive back stood out as having a rough night. Christian Gray was targeted 7 times and allowed 3 catches. That alone was actually OK; the problem was that those 3 catches went for 80 yards. Notre Dame's defense stood tall after some long catches. But Gray was almost dead last among defensive players in PFF's ratings with a 49.9 overall grade.

Winner - Nolan James Jr.

It’s been hard for any Notre Dame running back to stand out this year, as the Irish have gone with a three-headed monster. On Saturday night, Nolan James Jr. was the scariest. On just 15 carries, he tallied 98 yards and a touchdown. His 38-yard run was his second-longest of the season. His performance allowed James to leap into the team’s leading rusher spot with 742 yards, and he’s leading the Fighting Irish in rushing touchdowns by a wide margin with 11 scores.

Add us as a preferred source on Google